Organic Cotton Singlet vs Secret Shelf Singlet: Which Loungewear Top?
By The Very Good Bra | 100% Plastic-Free Bras & Underwear | Published: 2026-10-19
Category: Comparisons
Compare The Very Good Bra's organic cotton singlet and Secret Shelf Singlet for loungewear. Find out which top suits your support and comfort needs.
Quick Answer
Choose the organic cotton singlet for a relaxed, timeless fit, or the Secret Shelf Singlet if you want gentle built-in support without a bra. Both are plastic-free and made in Sydney.
Support vs. Freedom: The Main Trade-Off
The biggest difference between these two loungewear tops comes down to support. The Secret Shelf Singlet includes a hidden inner support layer secured by soft elastic and darts, so you get gentle lift and shaping without needing a separate bra. The organic cotton singlet, on the other hand, is a timeless, unstructured shape that gives you total freedom and a more relaxed feel.
Fabric and Construction: Both Plastic-Free
Both singlets are made in Sydney from 100% organic cotton, knitted and dyed in Melbourne. The Secret Shelf Singlet goes a step further with cellulose tencel sewing thread, meaning it contains no polyester sewing thread, nylon labelling, or other plastic components. The organic cotton singlet is also plastic-free, but the Secret Shelf's construction details make it the more explicitly eco-conscious choice for those who want every component to be plastic-free.
Fit and Sizing: Know Your Preference
The organic cotton singlet is designed to fit, so if you prefer a more relaxed fit, you should size up. The Secret Shelf Singlet is designed to be roomy, with the inner support providing gentle fit. This means the Secret Shelf may feel more secure and shaping, while the organic cotton singlet offers a looser, more casual drape.
How to Choose: Trade-Offs to Consider
- Support Needs: If you want light support and shaping, the Secret Shelf Singlet's inner support layer is the better choice. If you prefer no structure at all, the organic cotton singlet is more freeing. Consider what level of support you need for your daily activities.
- Fit Preference: The organic cotton singlet is designed to fit, so size up for a relaxed look. The Secret Shelf is roomy by design, so you get a loose fit with gentle support. Think about whether you prefer a snug or loose fit for loungewear.
- Plastic-Free Commitment: Both are plastic-free, but the Secret Shelf Singlet also uses cellulose tencel sewing thread and avoids nylon labelling, making it the more explicitly plastic-free option. Check the materials if you want every detail to be plastic-free.
At a Glance: Key Product Details
- Organic cotton singlet: Based on a loved old favourite, a timeless singlet shape that never goes out of style. Made in Sydney from 100% organic cotton, knitted and dyed in Melbourne. This is your go-to for a classic, unstructured loungewear top that works for sleep, lounging, and warm days.
Organic cotton singlet - Secret Shelf Singlet: A hidden support singlet secured by soft elastic and darts, made from 100% organic cotton with cellulose tencel sewing thread, containing no polyester sewing thread or nylon labelling. This option gives you gentle built-in support and is fully plastic-free, making it ideal for days when you want extra shaping without a bra.
Secret Shelf Singlet
Which Singlet Fits You?
Best for
- Those who want a classic, unstructured singlet for sleep, lounging, or warm days
- Anyone who prefers a relaxed fit and doesn't need built-in support
Not for
- Those who want gentle shaping and support without a bra—consider the Secret Shelf Singlet
